DOCUMENTARY：
Charlie Y. Cheng and
Victoria Forester Courtland ("V.C.")
Under construction: 2020-01-21 17:34

Thanks to attorneys Al Rinaldi, Spencer Hall, Scott J. Engelhard & L. Nassbaum !
感谢我的律师 Al Rinaldi、Spencer Hall、Scott Engelhard和Nassbaum！​

Thanks to Washington State Supreme Court Justice Sheryl G. MaCloud!
感谢华州最高法院大法官 Sheryl G. MaCloud！

The 2007 wrongful conviction against innocent Charlie Y. Cheng 
is part of American history.  American deserve to know it!
​华盛顿州2007年判无辜者入狱，是美国历史的一部分，值得了解它的真像！

​FACTS

          On 12/19/1998, Victoria Forester (AKA: Victoria Forester Courtland, "V.C.") was referred to me for her injury.   (Note:  According to V.C.'s 12/01/2006's statement, she'd referred me to her sister Susan, N.P. and friend Ms. O'Conner.)   See infra evidence.

          In 2001, before moving back to the East Coast, V.C. asked me to have pictures taken with her.  I was advised that our photo would be used for her future book about my Acuvibra healing art.  NOTE:  (1) On 06/05/2007, V.C. declared  publicly at the open court, "Anytime in the past I had gone to see him for an injury, I would have found great relief from his technique. I feel like on that level he (me) is like a healing force in my life."  (see infra);   (2) On 06/05/2007, V.C.'s husband declared  publicly at the open court, "Victoria had been talking about how great Dr. Cheng was befolre we went to Seattle ... I was glad she introduced him because it sound like they had a very good relationship."  (3) On 06/05/2007, V.C.'s sister declared  publicly at the open court, "She (V.C.) seemed to like him as practitioner." (See court official transcripts infra.)
​
          On 07/02/2002, V.C. discovered the fact that I'd won over K.R.'s and her two friends' 1998 false allegation against me (infra).  She  wanted to add this story to her future book about me. 

          In December of 2014, V.C. flew from the East Coast to Seattle with her 3-month-old daughter (her husband did not come to Seattle with them) assisting her sister's first labor.  Her sister's labor due day had been prolonged.  During the waiting period, V.C. came to my office three times to inspecting the 1998 documents of K.R.'s and K.R.'s two friends' 1998 allegations and took notes of K.R.'s contact information from the 1998 file. ( V.C. paid $48 for each visit).  NOTE:  In V.C.'s letter to the open Court dated September 7 of 2007, she disclosed a secret that she contacted K.R. and encouraged her to come forward again (see the court's official transcript, infra).

         During the 2014 visit to get more information about how I won the false 1998 allegations, she discovered that Prof. Alex Maxwell was going to write the same  story about me. She asked me not to cooperate with Prof. Maxwell anymore on  the basis that in 2001 she already had pictures taken with her for her future book about me.  

          In the third visit of 2004, she asked me to give her an exclusive right to write my story. I refused.  Also, I did not allow her to use the 2001 photos that showing she and me were shaking hands together in front of my clinic sign in her future book about me.  (See infra evidence.)      

          V.C.'s December-2004 visit was ended unhappy -- she left my office with angry. (See infra evidence.)  V.C. had my email and phone number, but either she or her husband did not write nor call me since then. 
​
          In Summer of 2005, V.C. called Washington State Sex Assaulted Center (WSSAC) asking how to make a sex assault report.  She was encouraged to call the Seattle  Police.  However, she didn't call.  Then, the WSSAC gave her follow-up call， but no feedback from V.C..     NOTE:  On June 5th of 2007 ,  V.C. declared publicly at the open court that she was afraid to call the Police because I (who  lives  in the West Coast) would kill her (who lives in the East Coast). (See infra evidence.)  

          After the December-2014 conflict, V.C. “met“ K.R., (who later became the State's witness against me for the 2007 trial) and encouraged K.R. “to come forward again.” (Citing from V.C.'s public statement dated 09/07/2007). (See infra evidence.)

          18 months later since the December 2004 conflict,  in June of 2006, V.C. called the Seattle Police from the East Coast and made a false report that she‘s benn sexually assaulted by me during a December-2004 treatment for her 'uterine prolapse'.  V.C. claimed that she had the prolapse problem since her daughter's birth in August of 2004.  The reason she didn't see O.B. or any physicians to treat the alleged 'uterine prolapse' in the past 3 months, but rather (waiting 3 months) to fly to Seattle to see me for a 'treatment' in December of 2004, V.C. told the jury that because she and I had a patient and doctor's relationship. (See infra evidence.)

          V.C. claimed that she'd told her Korean friend K. O'Connell about the alleged 'December-2004 assault.'  On 06/26/2006 Seattle Police detective Ms. S. interviewed with K.O. and wrote: "Ms. O'Connell doesn't remember specifically what kind of contact it was, or if V/Courtland even told her what Dr. Cheng did."   (See infra evidence.) On 04/09/2007, the Prosecutor's Office subpoenaed K.O. be the State's witness at the trial.  (See infra evidence.) But, K.O. didn't show up at the trial to support V.C.'s claim.

          V.C. claimed that she also told Dr. Howard Blum about the alleged 'December-2004 assault'.  Detective Ms. S. telephoned Dr. Blum on 06/30/2006 to verify V.C.'s claim.  She wrote that Dr. Blum was "one of the people to whom V/Courtland disclosed the incident with S/Cheng;" And,  Dr. Blum "doesn't remember a conversation with Victoria Courtland about this incident."  (See infra evidence.)

          On 6/7/2007, at the 2007 trial, Detective Ms. S. disclosed a secret to the Jury, "She (V.C.) told me that she had not been diagnosed with uterine prolapse at the time she saw him (me)." (See infra evidence.)
​
          On 09/07/2007, at the Superior Court of Washington State, V.C.'s letter was read publicly in which she made false calaim that I sexually assaulted her in a December-2004 treatment for her uterine prolapse.  She said that after she made the report, she became depressd. She asked the Court to order a $12,372.00 restitution against me. In order to get a restitution,  V.C. also claimed publicly that she and her 3-year-old daughter were 'victims' of mine.

          V.C.'s $12,372 restitution demanding was not granted by the Court expect couple hundred of dollars. (See infra evidence.)
​
          In 2015, V.C. read my website (this one) in which I revealed undeniable evidences demonstrating the fact that "V.C." made up the non-existing 2004 'sex crime' against  a moral health care provider for her own gains (infra). 

          In 2017, I published above memoir titled "FORGIVENESS: An Innocent Prisoner's Testimony" (ISBN 978-1-5136-2440-2) in which I gave the reason why I would forgive those who made false claims against me, because God's words to forgive. 
​
          In 2019, V.C. asked the Court to terminate her 2007 victim restitution of which she does not deserve.   (Note:  V.C.'s 2019 request has been printed on the cover of “FACTS:  Victoria Forester Courtland Created A Non-existing 2004 Sex Crime", see supra. ).

​          I'm Charlie Y. Cheng, a moral health care provider who had no criminal history before the false accusations created by Victoria Forester Courtland (AKA：Victoria Courtland, Victoria Forester, "V.C.") in 2006.
             在受到 V.C.的2006年诬告之前（详情介绍在后），我没有犯罪史。

            Before the 9/7/2007 sentencing hearing, the trial Judge of the Washington State Superior Court for cause No.  06-1-05678-3 (my case) received dozens of opposing letters in support of me because 'Mr. Cheng is not guilty' (quoted from defense lawyer Scott J. Engelhard, see below) . 
​           当我在2007年被陪审团误判后，庭审法官收到了大量反对误判的信件。因为我“是无罪的" （摘自辩护律师 Scott Engelhard在法庭上的话语，见下面）。

          On 9/9/2008, a year later after I being wrongfully convicted for an alleged sex crime (that was created by Dr. Victoria Forester Courtland but I did not commit),  Ms. Nussbaum, one of super appellate lawyers, wrote me:  
​           "You are an innocent man wrongfully caught up in the craziness and deceipt of these two women through no doing of your own ...  the trial judge made errors in your trial." （see below)
​         在我被冤判入狱后的第二年，华州一位著名的上诉律师写给我：“你（笔者）是位无辜者，被两位说谎的女人编的故事栽赃... 我认为庭审法官也有错。” （下面是上诉律师原信的有关部分)

          13 year ago in 2006, after making false report to the Seattle Police to hurt me, Dr. Victoria Forester Courtland became 'depressed' (see her statement to the open Court on September 7th, 2007, see infra). 
         In 2019, Dr. Courtland finally made a correct decision in asking the Court "to stop restitution payment to her" (citing Prosecutor David Ryan's letter (see below).
          在13年前的2006年，V.C.博士向西雅图警方报了假案来陷害我之后，她得了忧郁症（请见下面刊出的她2007年9月7日在公开法庭上的自白）。
​          经过13年的思想斗争之后，她终于在2019年做出了正确的决定：要求法庭终止我对她的赔款（请见下图检察官David Ryan 给我的来信）。

        On 6/13/2019, Prosecutor D. I. R. emailed me: "restitution payments to VC were terminated per attached order“ (see image FACT-A). 
​          在2019年6月13日，检察官来电邮通知我、有关V.C.博士2007年赔偿费的最新决议：”根据附件所示，VC的赔偿费已被要求终止“，（下图 FACT-A）。

         Below (FACT-B) is Prosecutor D. R.'s 6/13/2019 attachment, the "AGREED AMENDMENT TO ORDER SETTING RESTITUTION Dated 12/18/2007, TERMINATING PAYMENT TO V.C. (DOB ...)” signed by Judge Michael Ryan on 2/25/2019.   
       他说的 ”附件“ ，是华盛顿州法官在2019年2月25日签署的下面命令（见下图 FACT-B）。

       ​  The Superior Court's 2/25/2019 Order was prepared by the Prosecutor upon Dr. Courtland's request, it states, "V.C. does not want any future restitution or interest payments.  Therefore, restitution payment to V.C. (DOB ...) are terminated." (see FACT-B below) 
         最高法院的2019年2月25日命令是由检查官根据V.C.博士的要求而执笔。上面写着：”根据V.C.的请求，终止对V.C.的赔款”（见下面FACT-B)。

               Dr. Victoria Forester Courtland's motivation to participate in the 2007 trial had been documented in the official document of 9/7/2007 Washington State Superior court as asking for $12,372.00 (see FACT-C, below).
              VC博士出庭2007的动机是要求得到12万3百72美元的回报（见FACT-6, infra)。

            Usually, a victim will feel relaxed after reporting a bad person to the Police because his/her stress being released.  However, Dr. Courtland declared publicly at the 9/7/2007 Court, "After reporting Charlie Cheng to the Seattle Police I became so depressed ...” （see below transcript, lines 12-13).
              通常，受害人举报坏人后会感到心情轻松因为压力被减少了。但，VC博士在2007年9月7日的法庭上公开宣称：“自从我向西雅图警察局举报鄭先生之后，我心情变得诅丧 ..." （请见下面法院现场记录的第12-13行）。

        Regarding Victoria Forester Courtland's motivation to make the false 'sex assault' report, Scott J. Engelhard, defense attorney, informed the open Court, “my explanation as to her motivation for making false allegations against  Mr. Cheng." (See FACT-E.)

          In order to get a restitution to cover up travel cost and to treat 3-year-old daughter's bad habit of biting nails, at the 9/7/2007 open Court, Dr. Victoria Forester Courtland created non-existing fact of 'RAPE‘ against me (see FACT-D below).

​Victoria Forester Courtland ("V.C.") became a public figure after she disclosed her name at the public court (see below)

             Dr. Courtland (Victoria Forester) knew how to create stories. At the 6/5/2007 Washington State Superior Court, Victoria Forester Courtland declared publicly, "I'm an intelligent person" , and "I did teach creating writing."  (see FACT-1, below)

           Victoria Forester (Victoria Courtland) declared at the 6/5/2007 open Court, "I do like creating stories." (see below)
          在法庭上，V.C. 宣称：”我喜欢编故事" （见下面）。

The most famous story created by Dr. Courtland
was that "following ​the rape." (see supra FACT-D).
The others see "Q & A" sections (infra).

            Regarding Dr. Courtland's stories, Prosecutor Ms. Jensen pointed out:
​           "Ms. Courtland with her report ... is not exactly consistent with what she has said during her interviews.  There's something that's going to wheedle away her case, and the strenth of the State's case." (See below inmage FACT-2)
​
          关于如何评价VC博士编的故事，检查官Jensen说：“Courtland 女士在我们取证时的所讲,与她向KCSARC 机构的报案，有很大的出入。这将影响到我们的诉讼和消弱政府的这个案子。”（见下面FACT-2的法庭记录。）

​Below are part of Dr. Courtland's
inconsistent statements under oath.

        For example, one side, Dr. Courtland said that she had met State's another witness, Kathryn R. (the so-called 'victim') and encouraged her "to come forward again" (see below FACT-3).

             On another side under oath, Dr. Courtland would give a contrary story that she did "not' know Kathryn R.  (see fact 4 below).

           Dr. Courtland's other inconsistent stories (e.g., regarding whether she really talked with an acupuncture about the non-existing alleged 2004 assault, on 12/21/2006 she told the Prosecutor that the acupuncturist was "Kimberly Hughes"; then, at the 2007 trial, she changed to "Priscilla Xu"), please see infra Q & A Section.
         有关V.C.的其它前后不一的证词（比如，关于她是否有将她编造的2004受性性骚扰一事告诉过给针灸师，在2006年12月21日她告诉检方的，与她在2007年法庭上所讲的不一样），请看下面的<问与答>部分）。

        Regarding Victoria Forester's motivation, one side, at the 6/5/2007 open court, she said under oath, "we didn't need money” (see FACT-5 below).​   
        有关VC博士谎编的动机，一方面，在2007年6月5日的法庭上她宣誓称：“我不是为钱而来“（见FACT-5）。

​            On another side, at the 9/7/2007 Court, Dr. Courtland would make a 180-degree turn by asking a $12,372.00 of restitution to cover up her trip and to treat her 3-year-old daughter's biting nail habit (see FACT-6 below).
         另一方面，在2007年9月7日的法庭上，她却张口要1万2千3百72，说是要用来支付她的机票费、和用来给她3岁的女儿治疗咬手指甲的贵习惯用（见下面的FACT-6).

          Note:  even if Victoria Forester Courtland claimed that her daughter "has been a victim" of mine (see above lines 16-17 on FACT-6), 98% of her $12,372.00 of restitution demand was NOT granted by the Washington State Superior Court (supra).
         值得一提的是，即使是她声称，她三岁的女儿也是我的’受害者‘（见上面事实FACT-6的第16-17行），她所诉求的$12,372.00赔偿费的98%都被法庭拒绝了.​

          At the 2007 public trial, Dr. Courtland (Victoria Forester) presented to the Jury a non-existing 'fact' under oath that she's being sexually assaulted by me during the 'second treatment session' in December of 2004 for her uterine prolapse.
          In order to convince the Jury to believe the story,  Dr. Courtland told the Jury that she had talked with an acupuncturist, PRISCILLA XU (see Part B of Court transcript below).  It was contrary to her pre-trial interview, in which she said the acupuncturist was 'KIMBERLY HUGHES.' (see Part A of Court transcript below).
          Notably,  neither 'Kimberly Hughes' nor 'Priscilla Xu' had submitted affidavit to support Dr. Courtland's claims. 

                    Dr. Courtland's crucial false statement to the public made under oath was that she's being sexually assaulted by me during the 'second' session of treating her uterine prolapse in December of 2004!
                    I don't treat uterine prolapse!
                    This fact being documented in the old photos of my clinic sign and vehicle (see below). 
                       VC博士是在宣誓下说谎！因我从来不治疗‘子宫下垂’ 。有关我曾经的治疗范围，在我以前诊所招牌和车身上已有写出，没有讲治疗妇科（见下图）。

          Regarding the issue of whether Dr. Courtland was seeing me in 2004 for treating her 'uterine prolapse," at the 6/7/2007 trial court, Seattle Police Detective Stangeland disclosed two secrets to the public:  (1) Ms. Courtland was not see me for uterine prolapse, and (2) 'she had not been diagnosed with uterine prolapse at the time' she saw me in 2004 (see below).

          At the 2007 trial, under oath Dr. Courtland created a story that she was being sexually assaulted by me during her 'second' treatment session for her uterine prolapse in December, 2004.
           在2007法庭宣誓后，V.C.博士编了一个故事，说是她在2004年12月第二次找我给她治疗子宫下垂时，受到我的性骚扰。

         Regarding the issue whether there was the said 'second treatment', Mrs. Courtland and her husband (MR. Courtland) provided the following contradicted statements under oath：
​         (A) Mrs. Courtland told the Jury under oath that her mother took her for the said second treatment [see part (A) below].
         (B) MR. Courtland said that her wife's mother "did not attend“ [see part (B) below].
         关于是否有所谓的第二次治疗，V.C.说，是她母亲车她来来做第二次治疗的 【见下面 的（A）】；   但是，V她先生证词则完全同她的相反。他说，V.C. 的母亲根本就没在场 【见下面 (B)]。

            There is no clue why Dr. Courtland (Victoria Forester) actually made a false reported to the law enforcement regarding the non-existing 2004 treatment  (see Part B below), but she would claim under oath that "I was afraid to contact law enforcement' (see Part A below).

         The fact that I forgive Dr. Victoria Forester Courtland (Victoria Forester) who created non-existing ‘sex assault’ to hurt me, has been documented in my 2017 book, "FORGIVENESS: An Innocent Prisoner's Forgiveness"  with undeniable evidence (see below) .
         关于我原谅V.C. 博士谎编故事来陷害我的事实，已被记载在本人2007年出版的《要饶恕：一位无辜囚犯的见证》的回忆录中（见下）。

​Unfinished ... More  coming soon!     
​网站在编辑中，将会有更多精彩内容！
​

​Q1:     Have you had a fair trial?  你有没有受到公平的审判？

        No.  I didn't have a fair trial.  For example, my constitution right to have my own witness had been deprived by the trial Court (see Attorney Scott J. Engelhard's email dated 6/1/2007, below)    
     我是官方违反美国宪法第六修正案的受害者（法官不许我的女病人为我作证），（请看下面律师给我的电邮）。

​Q2：  What's your former female patients' response after you being convicted?

          After I was wrongfully convicted, Judge Nicole Macinnes received many of opposing letters from my former female patients.  Below is one of them.
          在我被冤判后，我的病人们纷纷写信给审判庭法官、替我伸冤。

Q3:     Is it true that Justice Sheryl G. MaCloud (she's a super defense lawyer in 2007) met you in person at King  County Jail, willing to assist your appeal?

           That's true.  
​
       当我在2007年6月13日被陪审团误判有罪后，华州最高法院现任大法官（当时她是上诉律师）亲自到监狱来看我、要求替我上诉。

​Q4:    In appellate lawyer Ms. Nussbaum's 9/9/2008 letter (supra), she wrote, "You are an innocent man wrongfully caught up in the craziness and deceipt of these two women through no doing of your own ."  who is another woman? 

                    "Kathryn R." (AKA: “K.R.", "Kathy P.") is the other woman who met Victoria Forester Courtland, which had been disclosed to the public via Dr. Courtland's public letter dated 9/7/2007 (see supra).
​                   "K.R." made false claim against me.  Below is the outline of K.R.'s case:

Q5:    Is it true that Dr. Courtland claimed that she told her husband about the alleged assault happened in the second session in 2004, but she could not recall when she told?
​
         Yes. That's true.

Q6：    After the appellate lawyer found that the 2007 conviction against you was the result of "the deceipt of these two women,"   why would you forgive them?   为什么在上诉律师发现、你冤判是‘两个撒谎的女子’的编造的，你却会原谅她们？

          I forgive "these two women" upon Jesus' teaching that “if you do not forgive, neither will your Father is in heaven forgive your trespasses.”   (see the POSTSCRIPT at pages 208-209 of "FORGIVENESS: An Innocent Prisoner's Testimony").
​                  之所以我选择了宽恕她们，是本着 耶稣的教导，“你们若不饶恕人，你们在天上的父也不饶恕你们的过犯” 。 有关此内容，已经在本人回忆录《我饶恕他们：一个无辜囚犯的证词》的第208-209页（《后记》篇）有登出。

Q7：   How Had you been treating by the DOC (Department of Corrections) at the prison?

           AI had been treating quiet respectfully by the officers of DOC (Department of Corrections) staff at the prison. 
​       I'd like to give special thanks to:  David Pittsenbarger, Melisa McVicker, Paul Barajas, George McCabe, Richard Brown, Jason Finke,  Craig Scott, Susan Poland, Belinda Caobin, R. Rambow, Brian Roberts, Nate Brum, Chad Chambers,  Sgt. Richairson, Sgt. Geoffrey Smith, Sgt. Semmon,  Sam Estep, Jannifer Ridgewood, Nicolas Lundgren, Michael King, Jason Finke,  Dennis Able,  Mr. Bellenger, Feresa R. Rees, Joa Chrispher, Hamble hardier,  Counselor Rollins, Counselor C. Steele, Counselor Devin Hughs, Conselor Curt McDonnal, etc.   

Q8：     Is Mr. Cheng's life in danger since he exposed this injustice case against him?
             本冤案实情在网上公布后，你会受到生命威胁吗？

                Yes, my life is facing danger after I exposed the truth that I was wrongfully convicted because of the existing bias and racialism！   是存在这种危险性，因为偏见和种族主义的存在！

Q9：     Why would Victoria Forester Courtland (V.C.) make false claims to hurt you?
              为什么 V.C. 要编谎话来陷害你？

​               I only remember that there was a dispute in the end of Dr. Courtland's third visit （which was not for treating her uterine prolapse as she claimed) in December of 2004 -- I reject her demand for an exclusive right to write my story because Prof. Alex Maxwell, who's my English editor for my three books in English, also wanted to write my story.  And, I did no allow V.C. to use the 2000-01 photo which showing she was shaking hands with me, in her book.

              In the end of the third visit, Victoria Forester Courtland left my office very angry. 

              NOTE:     Under oath, Dr. Courtland declared that she told her husband about the alleged sex assaulted after the so-called 'second treatment'.  According to Dr. Courtland,  her husband and her father then gave her a ride for third visit.  If it  were true, why her husband never mad at me?

​Q10:     What's Dr. Courtland's recollection about the said second treatment session for her uterine prolapse?

             Dr. Courtland said that after the alleged second treatment session, she left my office without fair (see the transcript below).

Q11:       Is it true that on 11/13/2001, the Department of Health (DOH) found that you were not guilty for K.R.'s 1998 complaint (the 
                Count One charge against you in the 2006) ?
           2006年起诉书给你罗列的第一项‘罪名’ 完全是K.R. 1998年的诬告，卫生厅调查该诬告的结果后、发现你没违规，对吗？

           A10:    Yes！The fact that I was NOT GUILTY for K.R.'s and her two friends' 1998 complaints had been documented on the DOH's 11/23/2001 order below.

​Unfinished ... More  coming soon!     网站在编辑中，将会有更多精彩内容！

​Q12:   When did you met Victoria Forester-Coutland?

                 I knew Victoria Forester-Courtland since 1998.  That time her name was "Victoria Forester".   She was referred to me by her friend "Mitch" (see below), a psychologist who's a years-long client of me, because Victoria Forester felt down from a ladder and injured herself during a work. 

​
​Q 13:   Was Victoria's surname "Courtland" when you saw her in 2002?

           ​It's not.  In 2002 Victoria's last name was "Forester", i.e., Victoria Forester,  (see below).​

Q 14:   Is it true that Victoria Forester Courtland had pictures taken with you in 2000?

              It's true!   In 2000, she drove from her graduate school in Bellingham, 79.45 miles north of Seattle, to my clinic asking me to have pictures taken with her (see below).  I was told that she would use it for her future book about me.

Q 15:     At the trial,  Victoria Forester Courtland told the Jury that the reason she didn't see any physicians at the East Coast (where she lives) for her painful 'uterine prolapse', but rather 3 more months to fly to Seattle (the West Coast) to see you, because she and you 'always' have a 'doctor and patient' relationship'.  Do you and Dr. Courtland always have a doctor and patient relationship as she claimed?
​
             ​​  No.
​

Q16:    Dr. Courtland claimed that she was assaulted by you in 2004.  Why she did not report to the Police in 2004, but waited to June of 2006?

          Regarding the issue why Dr. Courtland did not report to the Police in 2004 but rather waited to 2006, at the 6/5/2007 trial, she gave three reasons under oath:
        (1)  "I am afraid that ... there would be a  retribution for calling the police"; and
        (2)  "my greatest fear was that he would kill me, and it was a big fear.' (see her testimony below.)

Unfinished ... More  coming soon!     网站在编辑中，将会有更多精彩内容！

Under construction ...  more coming soon  
本网站仍在编辑中，请将建议电邮到：cyc1688@hotmail.com